Registered charity or non-profit? They are not the same thing
Incorporating does not make you a charity, and only a charity can issue tax receipts. The distinction catches out a great many new congregations and community organisations.
Here is the sequence we see repeatedly. A group incorporates — federally or provincially — as a non-profit. Donations start arriving. Somebody asks for a tax receipt. The treasurer, reasonably, assumes that being an incorporated non-profit is what makes that possible.
It is not. These are two separate statuses, granted by two different bodies, and you need both. If you already know you are registered and want the receipting rules, they are here.
Incorporation is not registration
| Incorporation | Charitable registration |
|---|---|
| Corporations Canada, or the province | Canada Revenue Agency |
| Creates the legal entity | Grants charitable status for tax purposes |
| Gives you a corporation number | Gives you a charitable registration number |
| Weeks | Months, and it can be refused |
| Does not permit tax receipts | Permits official donation receipts |
Only a registered charity — or another qualified donee — may issue an official donation receipt for income tax purposes. An incorporated non-profit without CRA registration cannot, no matter how worthy the work or how clearly the donation was a gift.
The one-question test
Do you have a charitable registration number from CRA? Not a corporation number, not a business number on its own — a charitable registration number. If no, you cannot issue official donation receipts.
What a non-registered non-profit can still do
Quite a lot, as long as nothing pretends to be a tax receipt.
- Accept donations and keep proper donor records.
- Give donors a written acknowledgement of what they gave.
- Issue an annual giving summary — a record for the donor’s own files, clearly marked as not a tax receipt.
- Operate, employ people, run programmes, and file its own returns.
What it must not do is issue anything a donor could mistake for an official receipt, or imply one is coming. A donor who claims a credit on a document that was never a valid receipt has a problem, and so does the organisation that gave it to them.
This is why BOGS EasyBooks will not let an organisation that is not marked as a registered charity generate anything called a receipt. It produces a giving summary instead, and prints on it, in terms, that it is not an official donation receipt and that the organisation is not registered with CRA. The restriction is the point.
Should you register?
Not automatically. Charitable registration brings real obligations: the annual T3010 information return, restrictions on activities and political work, rules about how funds are used, and the receipting regime with the penalties that go with it. Some organisations are better off not registering.
It is usually worth it if donations are a significant part of your funding and donors are asking for receipts, or if you want access to grants and funders that require charitable status. It is usually not worth it if you are mainly funded by membership fees, contracts or programme revenue.
If you have already issued receipts you were not entitled to issue
Do not quietly carry on, and do not simply stop and hope. It is fixable, and it is much more fixable before CRA raises it than after. Talk to somebody about it — us or another practice, but somebody.
What the application actually involves
CRA wants to see the organisation’s purposes, that those purposes are charitable at law, and a credible description of the activities that will carry them out. Vague statements of good intent are the usual reason an application stalls. “To advance religion” means something specific; “to help the community” does not.
Expect months rather than weeks, and expect follow-up questions.
We take organisations through all of it
Federal or provincial incorporation, extra-provincial registration, the charitable application, the corporate records, donation receipting and the annual return. Seven Winnipeg-area congregations and non-profits already run on it.
General information, not advice on your organisation’s situation, and not legal advice. It reflects CRA guidance as we read it on 29 October 2026. Whether a particular organisation qualifies for charitable registration depends on facts we do not know, and the decision is CRA’s. See CRA’s charities and giving pages. BOGS Accounting is a bookkeeping, payroll and tax practice in Winnipeg, Manitoba.
