Every product has every feature. That is why the feature list is useless.
Nine questions to ask before you pay for anything. Most of them have nothing to do with features, and three of them are where software built for somewhere else quietly falls down.
Most comparisons of bookkeeping software are lists of features, which is a poor way to choose one, because every product has every feature. What separates them is whether the thing fits how Canadian tax actually works and whether you will still be using it in March.
Here is what we would check, in the order we would check it.
1. Does it keep GST and provincial sales tax apart?
This is the first question and it eliminates more products than any other. In Manitoba you charge 12% — but it is two taxes, run by two governments, with two different rules.
- GST, 5%, federal. You get it back on business purchases through input tax credits. It is a receivable.
- RST, 7%, provincial. You do not get it back. It is a cost.
Software that treats “sales tax” as one recoverable bucket will overstate what you can reclaim and understate what your purchases cost. Open a trial, enter one purchase with both taxes on it, and look at where each one lands. If you cannot tell them apart afterwards, stop there.
2. Does it know your filing frequency — both of them?
Your GST reporting period and your RST reporting period are set separately and rarely line up.
GST: monthly and quarterly filers file and pay one month after the end of the reporting period; most annual filers have three months after their fiscal year end. A sole proprietor with a 31 December year end pays by 30 April and files by 15 June.
Manitoba RST: frequency follows what you collect — monthly if you average $5,000 or more a month, quarterly between $500 and $4,999, annually below $500. Returns and payment are generally due by 4:30 p.m. on the 20th, moving to the next working day if that is a weekend or statutory holiday.
What to look for
A product that asks you for both frequencies when you set it up knows they exist. One that asks for neither is going to tell you a deadline has passed.
3. How does a receipt get in?
Not “does it accept receipts” — everything does. How long does one take, from paper in hand to recorded and disposable?
If the answer involves a desktop, a scanner, or a folder you deal with later, the honest forecast is that you will do it for three weeks. The only capture habit that survives a busy month is the one that happens at the till, on the phone, in under ten seconds, with the supplier, date, amount and tax split read off the picture rather than typed.
This matters more than it sounds, for a reason in the next section.
4. Will it still hold your records in six years?
The CRA’s rule is six years from the end of the last tax year the records relate to. Some records — anything affecting the eventual sale, liquidation or wind-up of the business — are kept indefinitely. And you cannot simply decide you are done with them: destroying records early needs written permission from the CRA, by Form T137 or a letter to your tax services office.
So the question for any product is: if I stop paying for this, what happens to six years of documents? Can I get them out, in a form somebody else can read? A product that keeps your records hostage is not a record-keeping system.
5. Does it help you beat the four-year window?
The deadline nobody mentions. For most businesses, input tax credits must be claimed by the due date of the return for the last reporting period that ends within four years of when you could first have claimed them. Some larger and financial businesses get two years.
Nothing announces when that window shuts. No letter, no penalty — just GST you paid, that was yours to reclaim, and quietly stopped being claimable. Every receipt that never got entered is a small piece of that. It is the strongest practical argument for question 3.
6. Can you understand the screen without being taught?
Be honest about this one, because it decides whether you use the thing. If the first screen asks you to set up a chart of accounts, or expects you to know which side of an entry a purchase goes on, you are being handed an accountant’s tool. That is fine if you are an accountant.
If you are not, the test is simple: can you record a sale and an expense, correctly, within five minutes of signing up, without reading anything?
7. Does it do anything about getting you paid?
Issuing an invoice is not the job. Being paid is. Look for a product that sends the invoice, lets the customer pay from it, and chases the ones that go quiet without you having to remember which. The gap between invoicing weekly and invoicing monthly is about two weeks of cash, permanently, for no extra work.
8. What happens when you hire someone?
Payroll is where small businesses discover their software’s limits. Deductions, remittances on your assigned schedule, T4s by the last day of February, T5018s if you are in construction and pay subcontractors, and a record of employment every time somebody leaves.
The penalty for a late remittance is 3% at one to three days late and 10% beyond a week, charged on the whole amount over $500. Decide now whether you want the software to help you do that or whether you want somebody else to do it.
9. Is there a person at the other end?
At some point you will have a question that is about tax rather than software — whether something is deductible, which side a transaction belongs on, what to do about a figure that is wrong. A help desk cannot answer it. Knowing whether there is anyone who can is part of what you are buying.
Where BOGS EasyBooks stands on all nine
It was built in Winnipeg, for Canadian businesses, by a practice that does this work. GST and RST stay apart. Receipts go in from a photo, with the supplier, date, amount and category read off the picture. Invoices chase themselves. There is no chart of accounts to set up. From $9.99 a month, fourteen days free, no card needed to start.
If you have staff, the payroll half of question 8 has its own answer — payroll run for you rather than software to learn. And if you want the detail behind question 1, we set it out in Manitoba RST vs GST: what your business actually has to charge.
BOGS Accounting is a bookkeeping and tax practice in Winnipeg, Manitoba. This article is general information, not advice for your situation, and rules, rates and dates change. For the authoritative wording see the CRA on input tax credits, GST/HST reporting deadlines and keeping records, and Manitoba Finance’s Bulletin No. 004.


Leave a Reply