The deductions stop being yours the moment you withhold them.
The honest comparison, including the Manitoba payroll tax most small employers never have to pay and the penalty schedule that does most of the damage.
Payroll is the part of running a business that punishes being busy. Everything else can slip a week. This cannot, because the deductions you withhold stop being yours the moment you withhold them, and the penalty for being late is charged by formula on the whole amount.
So the question is not really “which payroll software”. It is whether this should be your job at all. Here is what each answer actually involves.
What the job is, when you do it yourself
Per pay period: collect the hours, calculate gross, calculate CPP, EI and income tax for each person, produce the pay, pay everyone, record the entries, and remit the deductions and the employer’s share to the CRA on your assigned schedule.
Per year: T4 slips to every employee and to the CRA, T5018 slips if you are in construction and pay subcontractors, a record of employment whenever someone leaves, and the reconciliation that makes the year’s remittances agree with the year’s slips.
None of it is difficult. All of it is dated, and the dates do not move for a busy week.
The penalty schedule, which is the real cost
| How late the remittance is | Penalty |
|---|---|
| 1 to 3 days | 3% |
| 4 to 5 days | 5% |
| 6 to 7 days | 7% |
| More than 7 days, or not remitted | 10% |
| Second or later assessment in the same calendar year, where the failure was knowing or grossly negligent | 20% |
These apply to amounts over $500. Read the first row again: three days late is 3% of the entire remittance, not 3% annualized. On a $9,000 remittance that is $270 for a long weekend.
T4s are their own schedule. They are due the last day of February, moving to the next business day when that is a weekend. A small employer filing one to fifty slips late pays $10 a day, to a maximum of $1,000, with a minimum penalty of $100. And once you file more than five information returns in a calendar year you are required to file electronically — a line small employers cross without noticing.
Nobody is late on purpose
In nearly every case we see, the money was there. What was missing was the number, because the hours had not been totalled and the pay run had not been finished. The penalty is for the paperwork, not the cash.
The Manitoba payroll tax — and why it probably does not apply to you
Manitoba has its own employer payroll tax, the Health and Post Secondary Education Tax Levy. Owners hear about it and worry. For most small employers in Winnipeg it is simply not in play:
| Total yearly payroll | Levy |
|---|---|
| $2.5 million or less | Exempt |
| Between $2.5 million and $5.0 million | 4.3% on the amount above $2.5 million |
| Over $5.0 million | 2.15% of the total payroll, with no deduction |
Associated groups of companies share one exemption based on their combined payroll, which is the detail that catches people who own more than one business. If your whole payroll is comfortably under $2.5 million, this is one thing you can stop thinking about.
Doing it yourself: when that is the right answer
It genuinely is, sometimes. Self-run payroll suits you when:
- Everyone is salaried and the numbers barely change between periods.
- You have two or three employees, no shift premiums, no overtime, no commission.
- Somebody in the business already knows the remittance dates and is reliably there in the week they fall.
- Nobody is joining or leaving often, so records of employment are rare.
Under those conditions payroll is twenty minutes a period and the software costs little. The failure mode is specific and worth naming: it breaks the first time the person who knows the schedule is away in the week the remittance is due.
Having it run for you: when that is the right answer
- Hours vary by person and period — trades, cleaning, hospitality, home care, security.
- There is overtime, there are statutory holidays, and someone has to decide how a stat falls for a part-time employee.
- People join and leave, so records of employment are a regular event rather than a rare one.
- You pay subcontractors as well as employees, and the T4 and T5018 lines need to stay apart.
- You are the person who would be doing it, and your hour is worth more spent on the work the business actually sells.
What “run for you” means at BOGS
Not software for you to learn. Your part is one screen per pay period: the dates are on it, the deadline is on it, and a reminder goes out by email before it closes. You enter hours by person, split by category where that matters, and approve. That is the end of your involvement.
After that it is ours: the deductions, the pay, the remittance to the CRA on your schedule, the T4s at year end. Nobody is paid before you say so — every period is approved by you, and the approval is kept.
Nothing to pay to ask
Payroll at BOGS is priced on what you actually need, and no account is created until you have agreed a figure. Tell us how many people and how often you pay them, and we will give you a price.
If the bookkeeping behind the payroll is also getting away from you, that is the other half of the same problem — see BOGS EasyBooks. And if what you want to know is simply when your own remittances are due, we set that out in CRA payroll remittance: the dates, the thresholds, and what late actually costs.
BOGS Accounting is a bookkeeping, payroll and tax practice in Winnipeg, Manitoba. This article is general information, not advice for your situation, and rates, thresholds and dates change. For the authoritative wording see the CRA on remitting source deductions and its guide to filing the T4 slip and summary, and Manitoba Finance on the Health and Post Secondary Education Tax Levy.


Leave a Reply